Sources: Mental Health Care Issues in America: An Encyclopedia | |
Bernadette A. Lear | |
Behavioral Sciences and Education Librarian, Penn State Harrisburg Library, Middletown, Pennsylvania |
Since the 1950s, deinstitutionalization has revolutionized how Americans receive mental health care. In the early twentieth century, acute or chronic patients were treated (and sometimes permanently confined) in residential facilities.
Now, the preferred courses are often counseling and medications. The stated purpose of Mental Health Care Issues in America: An Encyclopedia (MHCIiA) is to “provide an overview” of this shift, including its benefits and limitations (xv).
Although Shally-Jensen does not hold a related degree or work in the mental health field, many of MHCIiA’s contributors are faculty or graduate students in relevant disciplines within institutions offering APA or CSWE-accredited programs in Clinical Psychology or Social Work. MHCIiA includes approximately 115 entries arranged alphabetically and contains entries on many timely topics, such as insurance law, patient rights, and veteran’s mental health care. Each is typically 6–8 pages long and written at a high-school or early undergraduate reading level. Each includes bibliographies, notably containing numerous citations to current scholarly literature.
Various criticisms can be made of MHCIiA’s coverage. Given MHCIiA’s “Introduction,” which emphasizes the transition from residential to community-based care, I was surprised not to find more information about the system (or un-system?) itself. An entry on “Community Mental Health” briefly describes certain care models (assertive community treatment, case management, and family psychoeducation), but there seem to be no entries that describe the vast nonprofit sector which offers information and support to patients and caregivers. Likewise, the entries on “Insurance and Parity Laws;” “Poverty, Unemployment, Economic Inequality, and Mental Health;” “Preventative Mental Health Programs;” and “Workplace Issues and Mental Health” do not describe employee assistance programs and other in-house efforts to support workers’ mental health. Also, of 115 entries, approximately one-third address specific disorders, from Alzheimer’s disease, to Posttraumatic Stress Disorders, to Suicide. Typically, such entries provide information about prevalence, risk factors, causes, diagnostic criteria, the courses of the disorders, and interventions/treatments. Such basic information is already available through the American Psychological Association’s Help Center (a site for consumers, see www.apa.org/helpcenter/index.aspx), through MedlinePlus (for a list of mental health information available through this site, see www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/mentalhealthandbehavior.html), and through other reputable, specialized organizations such as the American Sleep Association (www.aasmnet.org) or CHADD (Children and Adults with ADHD, www.chadd.org). Thus a substantial portion of MHCIiA does not provide unique information.
There are several other reference sources besides MHCIiA, including the Gale Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 3rd ed. (Gale, 2012). For those interested in the medical model of treatment, the Gale Encyclopedia provides many more entries on assessments (such as the Children’s Depression Inventory); drug treatments (such as amphetamines, used for ADHD, depression, and obesity); and natural therapies (like ginkgo biloba, used for some patients with dementia). In addition, Sage offers entire encyclopedias on some of the topics which MHCIiA treats in single entries, including Sage’s Encyclopedia of Family Health (2011), Encyclopedia of Homelessness (2004), Encyclopedia of Interpersonal Violence (2008), and Encyclopedia of Substance Abuse Prevention, Treatment, and Recovery (2009).
In summary, MHCIiA may be appropriate for high school or public libraries with small collections which desire to offer a basic print source on mental health care. For libraries which already have substantial holdings in clinical psychology and social work, this is an optional purchase.
Article Categories:
|
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
© 2024 RUSA